Eighteen under-eye creams, and for once every single one publishes a rating count. Line those counts up against the prices and they point in opposite directions - which tells you about the shelf, not about the creams.
We read every under-eye cream Nykaa returned on 4 November 2026 - 18 distinct listings - and found something most shelves do not offer: every single one publishes a star average and a rating count. Set those counts beside the prices and they run in opposite directions. The four most-rated creams here all sell under Rs. 500; the four dearest, up to Rs. 2,155, all carry fewer than 1,100 ratings. That is a fact about how this shelf is priced and sold - not evidence that any cream works, which this page does not assess.
Every price below was pulled from Nykaa on November 4, 2026 and checked against the MRP on the listing. Stack them with the live codes on our Nykaa coupons page, which the deals desk re-verifies daily.
42%, 36%, 26% and 20% - and after this the shelf drops to 19% and below and stays there.
Rs. 189 against a stated Rs. 325, badged 42% — 7,282 ratings
Why it earned its spot the cheapest cream on the shelf and the biggest badge, on a rating pool of 7,282.
Rs. 255 against a stated Rs. 399, badged 36% — 4,049 ratings
Why it earned its spot the second-deepest badge, and the lowest star average in the read at 3.9.
Rs. 192 against a stated Rs. 259, badged 26% — 5,738 ratings
Why it earned its spot Rs. 3 dearer than the cheapest tile, with sixteen fewer badge points.
Rs. 472 against a stated Rs. 590, badged 20% — 1,318 ratings
Why it earned its spot the point where the shelf's badges drop into single and low double digits and mostly stay there.
Rs. 648 against a stated Rs. 800, badged 19% — 379 ratings
Why it earned its spot the fourth-dearest cream here, and one of four dear tiles with thin rating pools.
21,387, 21,114, 18,587 and 12,259 ratings, at Rs. 297, Rs. 406, Rs. 207 and Rs. 474.
Rs. 406 against a stated Rs. 495, badged 18% — 21,114 ratings
Why it earned its spot the second-largest rating pool in the read, at under half the price of the four dearest creams.
Rs. 297 against a stated Rs. 349, badged 15% — 21,387 ratings
Why it earned its spot the most-rated cream in the entire read, at Rs. 297.
Rs. 207 against a stated Rs. 235, badged 12% — 18,587 ratings
Why it earned its spot the third-most-rated cream here, and the second cheapest.
Rs. 474 against a stated Rs. 499, badged 5% — 12,259 ratings
Why it earned its spot the fourth-most-rated cream on the shelf, carrying one of its two shallowest badges.
Rs. 2,155 on 397 ratings and Rs. 1,700 on 21 - alongside six tiles whose stated MRPs sit barely above what they charge.
Rs. 1,700 against a stated Rs. 2,000, badged 15% — 21 ratings
Why it earned its spot the second-dearest cream in the read, resting on twenty-one ratings.
Rs. 340 against a stated Rs. 400, badged 15% — 3,333 ratings
Why it earned its spot the middle of the shelf on every measure - price, badge and rating pool.
Rs. 289 against a stated Rs. 325, badged 11% — 626 ratings
Why it earned its spot the same stated Rs. 325 as the cheapest tile in the read, at a 31-point shallower badge.
Rs. 359 against a stated Rs. 399, badged 10% — 2,859 ratings
Why it earned its spot the same stated Rs. 399 as pick 02, which sells Rs. 104 cheaper.
Rs. 449 against a stated Rs. 499, badged 10% — 142 ratings
Why it earned its spot a thin rating pool in the middle of the price band, unlike most tiles here.
Rs. 2,155 against a stated Rs. 2,394, badged 10% — 397 ratings
Why it earned its spot 11.4 times the price of the cheapest cream here, on 1.9% of the ratings of the most-rated one.
Rs. 401 against a stated Rs. 445, badged 10% — 3,083 ratings
Why it earned its spot another 1.11x claim, in the bunch of six tiles badged 9% to 11%.
Rs. 319 against a stated Rs. 349, badged 9% — 1,967 ratings
Why it earned its spot the same stated Rs. 349 as the most-rated cream here, at Rs. 22 more.
Rs. 759 against a stated Rs. 799, badged 5% — 1,048 ratings
Why it earned its spot the third-dearest cream, with the smallest claim multiple on the shelf.
Nykaa runs card and coupon offers that change by day, card and basket, and this read was made logged out, so no bank discount is included in any price here. Check the pack quantity first - these are per-pack prices and the packs are not comparable sizes. Check the rating count beside the stars, because one cream here carries 21 ratings and another 21,387. Read the badge as a fact about the stated MRP rather than about value, given the multiples here run only 1.05x to 1.72x. Check the ingredient list against anything you react to, plus the expiry and return terms on the live listing. And treat any percentage printed on the pack as the brand's marketing - nothing on this page verifies it, and a doctor is the right source for a medical concern.
| Product | Sale price | MRP | Discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bella Vita EyeLift — Rs. 189, badged 42%, the cheapest in the read | Rs. 189 | Rs. 325 | 42% |
| Conscious Chemist retinol peptide — Rs. 255, badged 36% | Rs. 255 | Rs. 399 | 36% |
| Himalaya under eye cream — Rs. 192, badged 26%, 5,738 ratings | Rs. 192 | Rs. 259 | 26% |
| Vilvah under eye cream — Rs. 472, badged 20% | Rs. 472 | Rs. 590 | 20% |
| SEREKO gel pen — Rs. 648, badged 19%, on 379 ratings | Rs. 648 | Rs. 800 | 19% |
| Dot & Key under eye cream — Rs. 406, on 21,114 ratings | Rs. 406 | Rs. 495 | 18% |
| MCaffeine coffee under eye cream — Rs. 297, the most-rated here | Rs. 297 | Rs. 349 | 15% |
| TIRTIR collagen lifting eye cream — Rs. 1,700, on 21 ratings | Rs. 1,700 | Rs. 2,000 | 15% |
| Pilgrim squalane roll-on — Rs. 340, badged 15% | Rs. 340 | Rs. 400 | 15% |
| Aroma Magic under eye gel — Rs. 207, on 18,587 ratings | Rs. 207 | Rs. 235 | 12% |
| Juicy Chemistry organic repair cream — Rs. 289, badged 11% | Rs. 289 | Rs. 325 | 11% |
| The Derma Co snail peptide — Rs. 359, badged 10% | Rs. 359 | Rs. 399 | 10% |
| Plum rice water & niacinamide — Rs. 449, on 142 ratings | Rs. 449 | Rs. 499 | 10% |
| Eucerin anti-pigment corrector — Rs. 2,155, the dearest in the read | Rs. 2,155 | Rs. 2,394 | 10% |
| O3+ eye circle cream — Rs. 401, badged 10% | Rs. 401 | Rs. 445 | 10% |
| Chemist at Play under eye cream — Rs. 319, badged 9% | Rs. 319 | Rs. 349 | 9% |
| Minimalist vitamin K + retinal — Rs. 474, badged 5%, 12,259 ratings | Rs. 474 | Rs. 499 | 5% |
| ClayCo ginseng cica cream — Rs. 759, badged 5%, the shallowest | Rs. 759 | Rs. 799 | 5% |
This is a price read of cosmetic products, and it is not health advice. Nothing here was used, applied or tested. Several of these listings and their pack images carry efficacy claims - percentages, before-and-after framing, timeframes like "in 2 weeks". Those are the brands' own marketing claims. This page does not repeat them as fact, does not assess them and does not endorse them. Nothing on this page says or implies that any cream here will reduce dark circles, puffiness, pigmentation or fine lines, or that a dearer one works better than a cheaper one. If you have a skin or eye concern, speak to a doctor rather than read a price page.
Each selling price, stated MRP, discount badge, star average and rating count came from the JSON nykaa.com's own product API serves, read on 4 November 2026, logged out, from India, with nothing bought. The read returned 18 distinct under-eye creams, and all 18 are on this page - the cheapest, the dearest, the most-rated and the least. Nothing was seated for being a good buy or dropped for being a bad one.
This page leans on rating counts because, unusually, all 18 listings in this read publish one - most shelves we read have large unrated gaps. But a rating count tells you how many people left a rating, not whether a product did anything. It is also shaped by how long a product has been listed and how heavily it has been marketed. We print the count beside every star average and render a star figure only where the pool is a thousand or more, because 4.4 stars on 21 ratings and 4.1 on 21,387 are not the same statement.
Where this page says one listing puts Rs. 325 behind a Rs. 189 cream, that is a figure Nykaa published. Setting a reference price above the selling price is an ordinary retail practice, and nothing here alleges wrongdoing by Nykaa or by any brand named. No stated MRP on this page is asserted to be false. The claim multiples on this shelf are unusually modest - 1.05x to 1.72x, where other shelves we read routinely carry 3x and 5x claims.
Under-eye creams on this shelf are sold in very different pack sizes, and the prices on this page are per pack, not per gram or millilitre. That matters: a Rs. 2,155 serum and a Rs. 189 gel may not contain comparable quantities, so the 11.4x price spread quoted here is a spread in pack prices and not in unit rates. We have not converted between the grams, millilitres and fluid ounces these listings use. Check the stated quantity on the live listing before comparing two figures.
Across 18 distinct under-eye creams read on 4 November 2026 from Nykaa's own product API, prices ran from Rs. 189 to Rs. 2,155 with a median of Rs. 380. Most of the shelf is cheap: twelve of the 18 sell under Rs. 500. The median displayed badge was 13.5%, and twelve of the 18 were badged 15% or less. Pack sizes vary and these are per-pack prices, not per-gram rates, so the 11.4x spread is not a like-for-like unit comparison. Prices change constantly - check the live listing before buying.
On this shelf, the opposite. The four most-rated creams in the read carry 21,387, 21,114, 18,587 and 12,259 ratings and sell at Rs. 297, Rs. 406, Rs. 207 and Rs. 474 - every one under Rs. 500. The four dearest creams, at Rs. 2,155, Rs. 1,700, Rs. 759 and Rs. 648, carry 397, 21, 1,048 and 379 ratings - not one reaches 1,100. This says nothing about which creams work. A rating count reflects how many buyers left a rating, which is driven by how long a product has been listed and how widely it has been sold, not by whether it did anything.
Because the stated reference prices on this shelf sit unusually close to the selling prices. The claim multiples run from 1.05x to 1.72x, with a median badge of 13.5%; twelve of the 18 are badged 15% or less and two are badged just 5%. For comparison, apparel and furniture shelves we read routinely carry 3x and 5x stated multiples producing 60% to 80% badges. A shallow badge is not evidence of a worse deal - on this shelf the two least-discounted creams include the fourth-most-rated one. Compare rupees, and the stated pack quantity, rather than badges.
We cannot tell you that, and this page does not try. Several listings in this read carry efficacy figures in their titles or on their pack images - reduction percentages, multiples, timeframes. Those are the brands' own marketing claims. Nothing on this page verifies, endorses or repeats them as fact, and we have not tested any product here. Such claims are typically based on company-run or company-commissioned consumer studies whose methods are not published on the listing. If an under-eye concern matters to you, a doctor is the right source - not a pack, and not a price page.
Check the pack quantity first - prices on this shelf are per pack and the packs are not the same size, so a Rs. 189 tube and a Rs. 2,155 one may not be comparable at all. Check the rating count alongside the stars: one cream here shows 4.4 stars on 21 ratings, another 4.1 on 21,387. Read the badge as information about the stated MRP, not about value, since the claim multiples here run only 1.05x to 1.72x. Check the ingredient list against anything you react to, and the expiry and return terms on the live listing. And treat efficacy claims on the pack as marketing - if you have a medical concern about your eyes or skin, ask a doctor.

















