We read Nykaa's own body-lotion listing and Amazon's own body-lotion search results on 18 November 2026, and the two shelves disclose opposite things. All 54 Nykaa listings carry a stated MRP and a discount badge, and not one of them states a volume. All 40 Amazon listings print a price per 100ml, and exactly one carries a discount badge.
You need both numbers to know what a bottle of lotion costs, and neither shop gives you both. On the four products sold under the same name on both sites, Amazon was cheaper on three — by Rs. 96 on a Vaseline lotion and Rs. 108 on a Mamaearth one that Nykaa badges at 55% off. Nothing here was bought, opened or applied, and no skincare claim on any listing is repeated or verified.
📅 Update log:
18 November 2026: first published. Every price, stated MRP, discount badge, per-100ml rate and rating count on this page was read on this date from nykaa.com's own body-lotion listing and amazon.in's own body-lotion search results, both logged out, from India, with nothing bought and no checkout completed on either site.
The short answer: each shop publishes the half the other leaves out
We read Nykaa's own body-lotion listing and Amazon's own body-lotion search results on 18 November 2026 — 54 listings on one, 40 on the other — and the two shelves disclose almost exactly opposite things.
All 54 Nykaa listings print a stated MRP and a discount badge. None of the 54 states a volume in its title. All 40 Amazon listings print a per-100ml rate on the tile itself. Just one of the 40 shows a discount badge. So Nykaa gives you the percentage and withholds the quantity; Amazon gives you the quantity rate and withholds the percentage. Neither gives you both, and you need both to know what a bottle costs.
| What the shelf publishes | Nykaa | Amazon |
|---|
| Listings read | 54 (17 unique) | 40 unique ASINs |
| Print a stated MRP and discount badge | 54 of 54 | 1 of 40 |
| State a volume in the listing title | 0 of 54 | 16 of 40 |
| Print a per-100ml rate on the tile | none | 40 of 40 |
| Price range | Rs. 245 - Rs. 1,187 | Rs. 120 - Rs. 1,999 |
| Median price | Rs. 399 | Rs. 349 |
| Median discount badge | 25% | not published |
| Per-100ml rate range | not published | Rs. 36 - Rs. 718, median Rs. 122 |
| Median rating count | 26,944 | 1,854 |
Amazon's per-unit rate was checked, not assumed. Three listings that state a volume in their own title were divided out: Rs. 235 for 600ml is Rs. 39.17 per 100ml against a printed 39; Rs. 599 for 300ml is Rs. 199.67 against a printed 199; Rs. 359 for 236ml is Rs. 152.12 against a printed 152. The figure Amazon prints on these tiles is therefore the price per 100ml. No equivalent figure exists on the Nykaa shelf, so none is computed for it anywhere on this page.
Four products sold under the same name on both shelves
Amazon was cheaper on three of the four, and the fourth was within five rupees. Vaseline's Gluta-Hya Dewy Radiance lotion was Rs. 311 on Nykaa, badged 25% off a stated Rs. 415, and Rs. 215 on Amazon for a 330ml bottle priced at Rs. 65 per 100ml — a gap of Rs. 96, or 31%.
The Mamaearth comparison is the one worth dwelling on. Nykaa sells the Rice Water Hydrating Body Lotion at Rs. 382, badged 55% off a stated Rs. 849 — the deepest discount among the four. Amazon sells listings of the same product name at Rs. 274, priced Rs. 68 per 100ml, and at Rs. 382, priced Rs. 63 per 100ml. That second Amazon listing is the identical rupee figure to Nykaa's, and Amazon's tile tells you it buys a bottle at Rs. 63 per 100ml. Nykaa's tile does not say what its Rs. 382 buys. This page therefore does NOT claim the two Rs. 382 listings are the same bottle — they may well not be, and nothing on the Nykaa listing allows the comparison to be made.
| Product | Nykaa price | Nykaa badge | Amazon price | Amazon unit rate | Gap |
|---|
| WishCare Sunscreen Body Lotion SPF50 PA++++ | Rs. 399 | 20% off Rs. 499 | Rs. 394 | Rs. 197 / 100ml | Rs. 5 |
| Mamaearth Rice Water Hydrating Body Lotion | Rs. 382 | 55% off Rs. 849 | Rs. 274 | Rs. 68 / 100ml | Rs. 108 |
| Vaseline Gluta-Hya Dewy Radiance | Rs. 311 | 25% off Rs. 415 | Rs. 215 | Rs. 65 / 100ml, 330ml | Rs. 96 |
| Joy Honey & Almonds body lotion (different variants) | Rs. 322 | 54% off Rs. 699 | Rs. 239 | Rs. 79 / 100ml, 300ml | Rs. 83 |
The Joy pair are different variants and are flagged as such. Nykaa's listing is the "Summer Lightweight" body lotion; Amazon's is the "Deep Nourishing" 300ml. They share a brand and a fragrance name but are not the same product, so the Rs. 83 gap in the table describes two related items rather than one item at two prices. The other three rows are listings of the same product name on both sites. Even there, no claim is made that the bottles are the same size, because Nykaa does not state a size.
Nykaa's review counts are fourteen times Amazon's
At the median, a Nykaa body-lotion listing in this read carried 26,944 ratings and an Amazon one carried 1,854. On the Vaseline Gluta-Hya line sold under the same name on both, it was 68,452 against 10,512; another Vaseline listing on Nykaa showed 172,891.
The likeliest explanation is that Nykaa pools reviews across a product's variants while Amazon splits them by listing, but Nykaa does not say so on these tiles and this page does not claim to know. The practical conclusion is that a Nykaa rating count and an Amazon one are not the same measurement and should not be read against each other. On Mamaearth's Rice Water lotion the direction reverses anyway — 1,213 on Nykaa against 1,658 on Amazon — which is a useful reminder that the gap is about how each site counts, not about which product is more popular.
| Product | Nykaa ratings | Amazon ratings | Ratio |
|---|
| WishCare Sunscreen Body Lotion SPF50 | 26,944 | 11,180 | 2.4x |
| Vaseline Gluta-Hya Dewy Radiance | 68,452 | 10,512 | 6.5x |
| Joy Honey & Almonds body lotion | 10,699 | 7,731 | 1.4x |
| Mamaearth Rice Water Hydrating Body Lotion | 1,213 | 1,658 | 0.7x |
| Median across the whole shelf | 26,944 | 1,854 | 14.5x |
The quick version: on Amazon, read the per-100ml rate under the price — it runs from Rs. 36 to Rs. 718 across this shelf and the headline price hides all of it. On Nykaa, open the product page for the volume before you compare anything, because the listing tile will not tell you.
How this comparison was made, in full
Sources, both read 18 November 2026, logged out, from India: nykaa.com's own body-lotion category listing (54 listings returned, 17 unique once variants repeating the identical name and price are collapsed) and amazon.in's own body-lotion search results (40 unique non-sponsored ASINs, sponsored placements dropped).
Nothing was bought, delivered, opened or applied, and no checkout was completed on either site. All prices are the logged-out, India-locale prices each site showed on that date.
Arithmetic shown as arithmetic. Price gaps are simple subtraction between the two sites' stated prices. Amazon's per-100ml rate is printed by Amazon on its own tiles and was verified against three listings that state a volume in their title (Rs. 235 ÷ 600ml = Rs. 39.17 against a printed 39; Rs. 599 ÷ 300ml = Rs. 199.67 against 199; Rs. 359 ÷ 236ml = Rs. 152.12 against 152). No per-millilitre figure is computed anywhere for any Nykaa listing, because no Nykaa listing in this read states a volume.
What this comparison cannot establish: whether any matched pair is the same bottle size. Three of the four matched rows are listings of the same product NAME on both sites, which is not the same as the same SKU; the Joy row is explicitly two different variants. A lower price on one site may simply be a smaller bottle, and on the Nykaa side there is no way to check from the listing. Prices, variants and availability change hourly on both sites.
This page assesses no skincare product. No claim about SPF performance, tan prevention, brightening, hydration, "glass skin", 48-hour claims, ingredient efficacy, safety, allergy risk or suitability for any skin type is made or repeated for any listing here. Phrases of that kind appear in sellers' own titles and packaging; this page records that they appear and verifies none of them. Check the ingredient list and expiry on the product page, and speak to a dermatologist about anything that matters to your skin.
The verdict
Treat the two shelves as giving you different halves of one sum. Nykaa's badge tells you the gap to a stated MRP and nothing about the bottle. Amazon's per-100ml rate tells you what the liquid costs and nothing about any discount. You need the first number from the second shelf and the second number from the first.
On the four products sold under the same name on both, Amazon was cheaper on three. Rs. 96 on the Vaseline, Rs. 108 on the Mamaearth, Rs. 83 on the Joy pair, and Rs. 5 on the WishCare. That is four products, not a verdict on two shops.
And do not read the rating counts against each other. Nykaa's median is fourteen times Amazon's on this shelf and 6.5 times on the one Vaseline product shared by both — but on the Mamaearth lotion Amazon's count is the larger. The two sites are counting differently, not measuring different popularity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is body lotion cheaper on Nykaa or Amazon in November 2026?
On the four products this read found under the same name on both sites, Amazon was cheaper on three and the two were within Rs. 5 on the fourth. Vaseline Gluta-Hya Dewy Radiance was Rs. 311 on Nykaa and Rs. 215 on Amazon, a gap of Rs. 96. Mamaearth Rice Water was Rs. 382 against Rs. 274, a gap of Rs. 108. WishCare's SPF50 body lotion was Rs. 399 against Rs. 394. Across the full shelves the median price was Rs. 399 on Nykaa and Rs. 349 on Amazon. But a straight price comparison is only sound where the two listings are the same size, and Nykaa states no size at all — so this is a comparison of four named products, not a verdict on the two shops. Read 18 November 2026, logged out, from India, with nothing bought.
Why can't you compare Nykaa body lotion prices per millilitre?
Because none of Nykaa's 54 listings in this read states a volume anywhere in the listing title. Amazon's 40 all print a per-100ml rate on the tile itself. So the arithmetic that makes two bottles comparable — price divided by millilitres — can be done on one shelf and not the other. The clearest illustration is the Mamaearth Rice Water lotion: Amazon sells it at Rs. 274 for a bottle priced at Rs. 68 per 100ml, and at Rs. 382 for one priced at Rs. 63 per 100ml — the bigger bottle, cheaper per millilitre. Nykaa sells the same product name at Rs. 382 and does not say which size that buys. This page therefore computes no per-millilitre figure for any Nykaa listing and does not guess one.
Why does Nykaa show so many more ratings than Amazon?
Nykaa's rating counts on this shelf are roughly fourteen times Amazon's at the median — 26,944 against 1,854. On the one Vaseline product sold under the same name on both, Nykaa publishes 68,452 ratings and Amazon 10,512, a gap of 6.5 times; on another Vaseline line Nykaa shows 172,891. The likeliest explanation is that Nykaa pools reviews across the variants of a product while Amazon splits them by listing, but Nykaa does not say so on these tiles and this page does not claim to know. What it does mean in practice is that a Nykaa rating count and an Amazon one are not the same measurement and should not be read against each other — and on Mamaearth's Rice Water lotion the direction reverses anyway: 1,213 on Nykaa against 1,658 on Amazon.
Does a 55% discount badge on Nykaa mean a cheaper body lotion?
Not on the evidence of this read. The deepest badge among the matched products was 55% off a stated Rs. 849 on Mamaearth's Rice Water lotion, giving Rs. 382 — and Amazon sold a listing of the same product name for Rs. 274, Rs. 108 less, with no discount badge on the tile at all. The Vaseline listing badged 25% on Nykaa at Rs. 311 was Rs. 215 on Amazon. Only 1 of Amazon's 40 listings showed a discount badge at all, so on that shelf the percentage simply is not part of the display. Stating a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful retail practice and no MRP quoted here is alleged to be false; the point is narrower, which is that a badge on one site cannot be compared with the absence of one on another.
What should you check before buying body lotion online?
The volume, first, and on one of these two shelves you will have to open the product page to find it. Amazon prints a per-100ml rate on every tile in this read; those rates ran from Rs. 36 to Rs. 718 per 100ml, which is a twenty-fold spread that the headline prices do not show. Nykaa's listing titles carried no volume at all, so the only way to compare two of its tiles is to open both. This page is a price read and nothing more — nothing here was bought, opened or applied, and no claim about SPF performance, brightening, hydration, ingredient efficacy, safety or suitability for any skin type is made or repeated for any listing. Check the ingredient list and the expiry on the product page itself, and consult a dermatologist about anything that matters to your skin.
Prices & codes last verified: November 18, 2026
Zoutons may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page. It does not change the prices above, which are Nykaa's and Amazon's own published figures as read on 18 November 2026, logged out, from India, with nothing bought and no checkout completed on either site. This page assesses no skincare product. No claim about SPF performance, tan prevention, brightening, hydration, 48-hour or "glass skin" claims, ingredient efficacy, safety, allergy risk or suitability for any skin type is made or repeated for any listing — such phrases appear in sellers' own titles and packaging and are verified by nobody here. Check the ingredient list and expiry on the product page and consult a dermatologist about anything that matters to your skin. Three of the four matched rows compare listings of the same product NAME on both sites, which is not the same as the same SKU, and Nykaa states no volume on any listing in this read — so a lower price on one site may be a smaller bottle, and no per-millilitre figure is computed for any Nykaa listing. The Joy row compares two different variants and says so. Amazon's per-100ml rate is Amazon's own printed figure, verified here against three listings that state a volume. Stating a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful retail practice and no stated MRP is alleged to be false. Prices, variants, badges and availability change hourly on both sites.