Read on one afternoon — 17 November 2026 — Myntra's makeup shelf and Nykaa's ask for the same money. The median Myntra listing sells at Rs. 335; the median Nykaa listing sells at Rs. 336. One rupee, across 125 listings.
The tiles tell a completely different story. Myntra's median badge is 40%; Nykaa's is 10%. Twenty-eight Myntra listings advertise 50% off or more, and not one of Nykaa's 54 does. Where the same palette appears on both — the MARS Poco Face, at Rs. 335 against a stated Rs. 349 — the badge is 4% on each. The gap is in the reference prices, and in one other number: Nykaa's median listing carries 5,267 ratings where Myntra's carries 224.
📅 Update log:
17 November 2026: first published. Every selling price, stated MRP, discount badge, star average and review count on this page was read on this date from each site's own listing data — myntra.com's window.__myx payload for the makeup-kit and eyeshadow paths (71 listings) and nykaa.com's own search API for the makeup kit, eyeshadow palette, blusher, highlighter, compact and face palette searches (54 listings) — logged out, from India, with nothing bought, no coupon applied and nothing opened or swatched.
The short answer: the same money, four times the percentage
Read on 17 November 2026, the two makeup shelves ask for almost exactly the same money. The median Myntra listing sells at Rs. 335; the median Nykaa listing sells at Rs. 336. One rupee apart across 125 listings.
What is not close is the advertising. The median Myntra tile advertises 40% off. The median Nykaa tile advertises 10%. Twenty-eight of Myntra's 71 listings badge 50% or deeper; not one of Nykaa's 54 does, and the deepest badge on the entire Nykaa shelf is 35%. The difference sits in the reference prices: a median stated MRP of 1.66 times the price on Myntra against 1.11 times on Nykaa.
| Myntra | Nykaa |
|---|
| Listings read | 71 | 54 |
| Cheapest | Rs. 194 | Rs. 97 |
| Median selling price | Rs. 335 | Rs. 336 |
| Dearest | Rs. 970 | Rs. 2,470 |
| Discount badge range | 0% to 87% | 3% to 35% |
| Median badge | 40% | 10% |
| Listings badging 50% or deeper | 28 of 71 | 0 of 54 |
| Median stated MRP as a multiple of price | 1.66x | 1.11x |
| Listings with a star rating | 70 of 71 | 54 of 54 |
| Median review count | 224 | 5,267 |
| Listings with 10,000+ ratings | 8 of 70 | 22 of 54 |
| Listings with under 500 ratings | 42 of 70 | 10 of 54 |
| Largest single review pool | 31,786 | 615,510 |
The quick version: near-identical median prices, wildly different badges, and review pools on Nykaa that are 23 times deeper at the median. The percentage is the least informative number on either tile.
One product, both sites, the same rupee
Seven brands appear on both shelves, but most list different products on each. One product matched exactly.
The MARS Poco Face palette sells at Rs. 335 against a stated Rs. 349 on Myntra, and at Rs. 335 against a stated Rs. 349 on Nykaa. Both tiles badge 4%. The only figures that move are the published reviews: 4.5 stars from 911 ratings on Myntra, 4.3 from 2,727 on Nykaa. That is the cleanest evidence on this page that the badge gap between the two shelves is a property of which products each one stocks and how each sets its reference prices — not of what a shopper pays for the same palette.
| Site | Listing | Price | Stated MRP | Badge | Ratings |
|---|
| Myntra | MARS Poco Face Makeup Eyeshadow with Highlighter, Blusher and Compact, 20g, Core 03 | Rs. 335 | Rs. 349 | 4% | 4.5 stars, 911 ratings |
| Nykaa | MARS Poco Face Makeup and Eyeshadow Palette | Rs. 335 | Rs. 349 | 4% | 4.3 stars, 2,727 ratings |
The six brands you can check on both shelves
Where a brand appears on both sites, the comparison is between that brand's ranges, not between two price tags on one item. MARS is the clearest case: nine listings on Myntra and eleven on Nykaa, both with a median price of exactly Rs. 335, and median badges of 8% and 5%.
Lakme and Blue Heaven run the other way. Myntra lists one Lakme kit at Rs. 427 badged 55%, where Nykaa's six Lakme listings badge a median 17% at a median Rs. 574. Myntra's single Blue Heaven listing is Rs. 559 badged 65%; Nykaa's is Rs. 97 badged 3%. These are different products under one brand name, and no claim is made that any of them is the same item.
| Brand | On Myntra | On Nykaa |
|---|
| MARS | 9 listings, median Rs. 335, median badge 8% | 11 listings, median Rs. 335, median badge 5% |
| Swiss Beauty | 6 listings, median Rs. 379, median badge 10% | 8 listings, median Rs. 282, median badge 15% |
| Lakme | 1 listing, Rs. 427, badge 55% | 6 listings, median Rs. 574, median badge 17% |
| Hilary Rhoda | 6 listings, median Rs. 286, median badge 18% | 3 listings, median Rs. 199, median badge 15% |
| Faces Canada | 1 listing, Rs. 749, badge 25% | 2 listings, median Rs. 334, median badge 17% |
| Blue Heaven | 1 listing, Rs. 559, badge 65% | 1 listing, Rs. 97, badge 3% |
Where the two shelves end
Myntra's deepest badge is 87%, on a 17-piece beginner kit at Rs. 334 against a stated Rs. 2,499 — a 7.48x multiple, standing on 195 ratings. Nykaa's deepest is 35%, on a compact at Rs. 155 against a stated Rs. 239 — standing on 465,885 ratings.
At the shallow end Myntra reaches 0%, on a MARS palette selling at exactly its stated Rs. 299 with 31,786 ratings behind it — the most-reviewed listing on that shelf, advertising nothing. Nykaa's shallowest is 3%, on a lip and cheek tint at Rs. 112 against Rs. 115, with 44,451 ratings.
| Listing | Price | Stated MRP | Badge | Ratings |
|---|
| Deepest badge on Myntra | G4U 17-piece beginner makeup kit | Rs. 334 | Rs. 2,499 | 87% | 195 ratings |
| Shallowest badge on Myntra | MARS 12-shade Dance Of Joy palette | Rs. 299 | Rs. 299 | 0% | 31,786 ratings |
| Deepest badge on Nykaa | Nykaa Cosmetics All Day Matte 12HR compact | Rs. 155 | Rs. 239 | 35% | 465,885 ratings |
| Shallowest badge on Nykaa | Insight Cosmetics Lip & Cheek Tint | Rs. 112 | Rs. 115 | 3% | 44,451 ratings |
Read the count, not just the stars. A 4.4-star average on this page stands on anything from 15 ratings to 615,510. Both numbers are published on both sites, and only one of them tells you how much the average is worth.
How these two shelves were read, in full
Myntra: myntra.com's own listing payload (window.__myx) for the makeup-kit path across two pages and the eyeshadow path, read 17 November 2026, logged out, from India. 71 listings after de-duplication by product id.
Nykaa: nykaa.com's own search API for the makeup kit, eyeshadow palette, blusher, highlighter, compact and face palette searches, read the same afternoon, logged out, from India. 54 listings after de-duplication.
Every price, stated MRP, discount badge, star average and review count on this page is the site's own published figure. Medians, ranges, counts and multiples are arithmetic on those figures and are computed over all 71 and all 54 listings respectively. No coupon, bank offer, loyalty price or logged-in price is included, because both reads were made logged out. Prices on both sites change daily.
Nothing was bought, delivered, opened or swatched. No claim about pigmentation, shade range, shade accuracy, wear time, fragrance, skin suitability or ingredient quality is made or repeated for any listing on either site, and product titles are quoted as each site publishes them. Anyone with sensitive skin or a known allergy should read the seller's own ingredient list on the product page.
The verdict
There is no cheaper site here. There is a louder one. Rs. 335 against Rs. 336 at the median, 40% against 10% on the tile, and a stated MRP that sits 1.66 times above the price on one shelf and 1.11 times on the other.
Where the two can be compared directly — the MARS Poco palette — the price, the stated MRP and the badge are all identical. The one real difference between these shelves is evidence: Nykaa's median listing carries 5,267 ratings and Myntra's carries 224. If you are buying something you have never used, that is the number worth reading.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Myntra or Nykaa cheaper for makeup kits in November 2026?
On this read, neither — the two shelves sit one rupee apart at the median. Across 71 Myntra makeup listings the median selling price is Rs. 335; across 54 Nykaa listings it is Rs. 336. What differs is the advertising: the median Myntra tile says 40% off and the median Nykaa tile says 10%. The ranges differ at the edges — Nykaa goes cheaper (Rs. 97) and much dearer (Rs. 2,470) than Myntra's Rs. 194 to Rs. 970. Both read 17 November 2026, logged out, from India, nothing bought.
Why are Myntra's makeup discounts so much bigger than Nykaa's?
Because the reference prices are set differently, not because the money is. The median Myntra listing states an MRP 1.66 times its selling price; the median Nykaa listing states 1.11 times. Twenty-eight of Myntra's 71 listings badge 50% or deeper. Not one of Nykaa's 54 does — the deepest badge on the whole Nykaa shelf is 35%. And where the same product appears on both, the badge is identical: the MARS Poco Face palette sells at Rs. 335 against a stated Rs. 349 on both sites, badged 4% on each. Printing a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful practice and nothing improper is alleged.
Is there a makeup product priced the same on Myntra and Nykaa?
Yes — one, in this read, to the rupee. The MARS Poco Face palette sells at Rs. 335 against a stated Rs. 349 on both sites, badged 4% on both. The only figures that differ are the published reviews: Myntra shows 4.5 stars from 911 ratings, Nykaa 4.3 stars from 2,727. Seven brands appear on both shelves altogether — MARS, Swiss Beauty, Lakme, Hilary Rhoda, Faces Canada, Blue Heaven and Milagro Beauty — but most list different products on each, so this is the only exact match the read produced.
Which site has more makeup reviews, Myntra or Nykaa?
Nykaa, by a factor of more than twenty at the median. The median Nykaa listing in this read carries 5,267 ratings; the median Myntra listing carries 224. Twenty-two of Nykaa's 54 listings carry 10,000 ratings or more, against eight of Myntra's 71 — and 42 of Myntra's 70 rated listings carry fewer than 500. The largest single pool on Nykaa is 615,510 ratings; on Myntra it is 31,786. Both sites publish a star average on nearly everything: 54 of 54 on Nykaa, 70 of 71 on Myntra. The star averages are close — the amount of evidence behind them is not.
What should I check before buying makeup on either site?
Compare rupees, not badges. The two shelves are one rupee apart at the median and four times apart on the advertised percentage. Read the review count beside the stars: 4.4 from 615,510 and 4.4 from 15 are not the same information, and both patterns appear here. Check the stated multiple rather than the percentage — the medians are 1.66x and 1.11x. Check the other site for the same product, since seven brands list on both. And remember nothing on this page was opened or swatched — no claim about pigmentation, wear time or skin suitability is made for either site, and anyone with sensitive skin should read the seller's own ingredient list.
Prices & codes last verified: November 17, 2026
Zoutons may earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page. It does not change the prices above, which are Myntra's and Nykaa's own published figures as read on 17 November 2026, logged out, from India. Prices, stated MRPs and discount badges on both sites change daily and may differ by account, session and location — check the live listing before buying. Nothing on this page was bought, delivered, opened or swatched, and no claim is made about pigmentation, shade accuracy, wear time, fragrance, skin suitability or ingredient quality. Anyone with sensitive skin or a known allergy should read the seller's own ingredient list on the product page. Printing a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful retail practice and no MRP here is alleged to be false.