Seventy-one makeup listings read in one morning. Two of them cost exactly Rs. 299 — one advertises 81% off and has no reviews, the other advertises nothing and has 31,786.
We read every makeup kit and eyeshadow palette Myntra returned on 17 November 2026 — 71 listings — and two of them cost exactly the same. A MARS palette asks Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 299, advertises 0% off, and carries 31,786 ratings. A NOY kit asks the same Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 1,593, advertises 81% off, and carries no rating at all. That split runs through the whole shelf: the brands printing the deepest badges have the thinnest review pools, and the brands printing almost no discount have the thickest. It is a tendency rather than a law — one palette here breaks it flatly — and that one is seated below too.
Every price below was pulled from Myntra on November 17, 2026 and checked against the MRP on the listing. Stack them with the live codes on our Myntra coupons page, which the deals desk re-verifies daily.
NOY sells at a median Rs. 299 and badges 82% on 32 ratings. MARS sells at a median Rs. 335 and badges 8% on 5,326.
Rs. 261 against a stated Rs. 1,494, badged 83%
Why it earned its spot the deep-badge world in one tile: a big reference price and 39 reviews.
Rs. 275 against a stated Rs. 299, badged 8%
Why it earned its spot Rs. 14 dearer than pick 1, seventy-five badge points shallower.
Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 299, badged 0%
Why it earned its spot the most-reviewed item on the shelf, and it advertises nothing off.
Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 1,593, badged 81%
Why it earned its spot identical money to pick 3, eighty-one badge points apart, no reviews.
Rs. 194 against a stated Rs. 1,299, badged 85%
Why it earned its spot the cheapest in the read, and the counterexample to this whole page.
Three tiles publishing 17,875 ratings sell at Rs. 463, Rs. 749 and Rs. 363. Three publishing 5,231 split 18% and 4%.
Rs. 463 against a stated Rs. 799, badged 42%
Why it earned its spot the first of three tiles publishing the identical 17,875 ratings.
Rs. 749 against a stated Rs. 899, badged 17%
Why it earned its spot Rs. 286 dearer than pick 6, on the same 17,875 reviews.
Rs. 363 against a stated Rs. 899, badged 60%
Why it earned its spot the cheapest of the three, from the same pool, against the same MRP.
Rs. 286 against a stated Rs. 349, badged 18%
Why it earned its spot one of three Hilary Rhoda tiles publishing the identical 5,231 ratings.
Rs. 286 against a stated Rs. 299, badged 4%
Why it earned its spot the same brand, the same rupee, the same review pool, a different MRP.
Every NOY tile in this read states Rs. 1,494, Rs. 1,593 or Rs. 2,024 — and never badges outside 81-83%.
Rs. 351 against a stated Rs. 2,024, badged 83%
Why it earned its spot the largest reference price NOY states, and 546 ratings behind it.
Rs. 354 against a stated Rs. 2,024, badged 83%
Why it earned its spot Rs. 3 dearer than pick 11, against the identical reference price.
Rs. 298 against a stated Rs. 1,593, badged 81%
Why it earned its spot the middle of NOY's three stated MRPs, on 32 ratings.
Rs. 265 against a stated Rs. 1,494, badged 82%
Why it earned its spot seven published ratings, and a tile that advertises 82% off.
Rs. 334 against a stated Rs. 2,499, badged 87%
Why it earned its spot the deepest badge and the biggest stated MRP of all 71 listings.
A 1% badge, MARS at its deepest 13%, and the brands in the middle that fit neither camp.
Rs. 296 against a stated Rs. 299, badged 1%
Why it earned its spot the shallowest badge on the shelf, three rupees off.
Rs. 347 against a stated Rs. 399, badged 13%
Why it earned its spot MARS's deepest badge in the read, which is still 13%.
Rs. 427 against a stated Rs. 949, badged 55%
Why it earned its spot a mass-market house brand sitting squarely between the two camps.
Rs. 796 against a stated Rs. 1,350, badged 41%
Why it earned its spot 7,080 ratings at the dear end, and a badge at the shelf median.
Rs. 970 against a stated Rs. 1,299, badged 25%
Why it earned its spot the dearest listing in the read.
Myntra runs coupon and bank offers that change by day, card and basket, and this read was made logged out, so nothing beyond the listed price is included here. Compare rupees, not badges — the 0% tile in this read costs the same as an 81% one. Read the review count, not only the stars: 4.1 from 39 ratings and 4.5 from 31,786 are not the same evidence. Check whether another tile shares the review count, since three listings here publish 17,875 across a Rs. 386 price spread. Read the stated MRP rather than the percentage — the multiples here run 1.00x to 7.48x, and the same pattern shows up in our Myntra lip gloss and hair brush read, where one 76,957-rating pool sits behind several tiles. If you are pricing the same aisle elsewhere, the Nykaa sheet mask shelf was read the same way.
| Product | Sale price | MRP | Discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| NOY 10-piece kit, Rs. 261 — 83% off a stated Rs. 1,494, 39 ratings | Rs. 261 | Rs. 1,494 | 83% |
| MARS Back to Basics palette, Rs. 275 — 8% off, 20,768 ratings | Rs. 275 | Rs. 299 | 8% |
| MARS Dance Of Joy palette, Rs. 299 — 0% off, 31,786 ratings | Rs. 299 | Rs. 299 | 0% |
| NOY all-in-one combo, Rs. 299 — 81% off, no rating published | Rs. 299 | Rs. 1,593 | 81% |
| MINARA eyeshadow palette, Rs. 194 — the floor, and 8,412 ratings | Rs. 194 | Rs. 1,299 | 85% |
| Revolution Reloaded Affection, Rs. 463 — 42%, pool of 17,875 | Rs. 463 | Rs. 799 | 42% |
| Revolution Reloaded Velvet Rose, Rs. 749 — 17%, same 17,875 | Rs. 749 | Rs. 899 | 17% |
| Revolution Marvellous Mattes, Rs. 363 — 60%, same 17,875 | Rs. 363 | Rs. 899 | 60% |
| Hilary Rhoda Perfection Shade 3, Rs. 286 — 18%, pool of 5,231 | Rs. 286 | Rs. 349 | 18% |
| Hilary Rhoda Perfection Shade 2, Rs. 286 — 4%, same 5,231 | Rs. 286 | Rs. 299 | 4% |
| NOY Opulence 15-piece, Rs. 351 — 83% off a stated Rs. 2,024 | Rs. 351 | Rs. 2,024 | 83% |
| NOY Radiance 15-piece, Rs. 354 — the same Rs. 2,024 again | Rs. 354 | Rs. 2,024 | 83% |
| NOY 11-piece kit, Rs. 298 — 81% off a stated Rs. 1,593 | Rs. 298 | Rs. 1,593 | 81% |
| NOY all-in-one, Rs. 265 — 82%, on 7 published ratings | Rs. 265 | Rs. 1,494 | 82% |
| G4U 17-piece beginner set, Rs. 334 — 87%, the deepest badge here | Rs. 334 | Rs. 2,499 | 87% |
| SWISS BEAUTY Take Me Anywhere kit, Rs. 296 — 1% off | Rs. 296 | Rs. 299 | 1% |
| MARS 9-shade all-in-one kit, Rs. 347 — 13%, 1,818 ratings | Rs. 347 | Rs. 399 | 13% |
| Lakme 9to5 Eyeconic regime kit, Rs. 427 — 55% off a stated Rs. 949 | Rs. 427 | Rs. 949 | 55% |
| ELLE 18 I'm Obsessed kit, Rs. 796 — 41%, 7,080 ratings | Rs. 796 | Rs. 1,350 | 41% |
| Maliao 45-shade palette, Rs. 970 — the ceiling of this shelf | Rs. 970 | Rs. 1,299 | 25% |
Each selling price, stated MRP, badge, star average and review count came from myntra.com's own listing payload for the makeup-kit and eyeshadow paths, read 17 November 2026, logged out, from India, with nothing bought and no coupon applied. 71 listings came back and every median, range, count and brand figure quoted on this page is computed over all 71 — not only over the twenty seated below.
Seventy of the 71 listings carry a star average and a review count; one carries neither, and the card for it shows no rating pill at all. No editorial score is invented anywhere on this page. Where several cards share an identical review count, that is Myntra's published figure, repeated.
Review pools attach to a product rather than to a tile, so an identical count across several listings is the strongest available signal that one item is listed more than once. It is not proof. Nothing was ordered, so no claim is made that any two listings on this page are the same palette — only that Myntra publishes the same review count, the same star average and, in two cases, the same price against different stated MRPs.
Printing a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful retail practice, and no claim is made that any MRP on this page is false. The multiple is given beside every badge — 1.00x at the shallowest, 7.48x at the deepest — so the reference price can be read directly rather than through a percentage.
This is a price read. No claim about pigmentation, shade range, shade accuracy, wear time, skin suitability, fragrance or ingredient quality is made or repeated anywhere on this page, and product titles are quoted exactly as Myntra publishes them. Anyone with sensitive skin or a known allergy should read the seller's own ingredient list on the product page.
Rs. 194 to Rs. 970 across the 71 makeup-kit and eyeshadow listings in this read, with a median of Rs. 335. The median badge is 40% and badges run from 0% to 87%. The cheapest is a MINARA eyeshadow palette at Rs. 194 badged 85%; the dearest is a Maliao 45-shade palette at Rs. 970 badged 25%. Read 17 November 2026 from Myntra's own listing data, logged out, nothing bought. Prices change daily — check the live listing.
Because the badge is calculated against each seller's own stated MRP, and the two sellers state very different ones. In this read a MARS palette sells at Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 299 — a 0% badge, while a NOY kit sells at Rs. 299 against a stated Rs. 1,593 — 81%, a 5.33x multiple. Identical money; eighty-one badge points apart on the tile. The clearest single example is Hilary Rhoda: two listings at the same Rs. 286 and the same 5,231 reviews, one stating Rs. 349 and badged 18%, the other stating Rs. 299 and badged 4%. Printing a reference price above a selling price is ordinary and lawful practice and nothing improper is alleged — but the percentage describes the reference price, not your saving.
Usually far fewer, on this read. The 13 NOY listings badge 81-83% and carry a median of 32 ratings; the 9 MARS listings badge 0-13% and carry a median of 5,326. G4U badges 79-87% on a median of 85 ratings. But it is a tendency, not a rule: a MINARA palette here sells at Rs. 194, badges 85% and carries 8,412 ratings, and SWISS BEAUTY badges a shallow 10% median on only 191. Read the count beside the stars before you read the percentage.
It usually means one product is listed more than once, because a review pool attaches to a product rather than to an individual tile. In this read three Makeup Revolution London tiles all publish 17,875 ratings and 4.4 stars, and sell at Rs. 463, Rs. 749 and Rs. 363 — badged 42%, 17% and 60%. Three Hilary Rhoda tiles all publish 5,231, and two MARS tiles both publish 20,768 at the identical price and MRP. This is a fingerprint, not proof — nothing was ordered, and no claim is made that any two of them are the same item. It is still worth checking the other tiles before paying the higher price.
Compare rupees, not badges. The 0% tile in this read costs the same Rs. 299 as an 81% one. Read the review count, not just the stars — 4.1 stars from 39 ratings and 4.5 from 31,786 are not the same evidence. Search the brand and shade before paying, since three tiles here share one review pool and a Rs. 386 price spread. Check the stated MRP: the multiples on this page run 1.00x to 7.48x. And remember nothing here was opened or swatched — no claim about pigmentation, wear time or skin suitability is made on this page, and anyone with sensitive skin should read the seller's own ingredient list.



















